1. Home
  2. /
  3. Politics
  4. /
  5. Slideshow
  6. /
  7. Supreme Court Declines Case...

Supreme Court Declines Case on College Bias Response Teams


The Supreme Court has chosen not to intervene in a case involving the constitutionality of college bias response teams, marking a significant development in the ongoing debate over free speech on university campuses.


Anonymous Reporting Platform

Credits: DepositPhotos

The case, brought forth by Speech First, an organization advocating for students’ free speech rights, centered on Virginia Tech’s policy allowing students to anonymously report bias incidents.


Case Deemed Moot

Credits: DepositPhotos

Speech First petitioned the Supreme Court after a lower court dismissed its lawsuit against Virginia Tech’s bias response policy. However, with Virginia Tech discontinuing its bias response team, the Supreme Court deemed the case moot and vacated the lower court’s ruling.


Relevancy Questioned

Credits: DepositPhotos

This decision follows a trend where the Supreme Court refrains from addressing cases it deems no longer relevant due to changed circumstances.


Dissension From Majority Opinion

Credits: DepositPhotos

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, known for her liberal views, dissented from the majority opinion, arguing that the party seeking vacatur had not demonstrated an equitable entitlement to the remedy.


Concerns Raised

Credits: DepositPhotos

Meanwhile, conservative Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito expressed concerns about bias response policies infringing on students’ speech rights and indicated a desire to review the First Amendment challenge.


Teams Spark Controversy

Credit: DepositPhotos

Virginia Tech’s bias response team allowed students to report perceived bias incidents anonymously, leading to voluntary meetings with university officials. While these teams have sparked controversy, they typically lack the authority to punish students directly, referring cases to other university bodies.


Less Chance of Self-Censorship

Credit: DepositPhotos

The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals previously ruled that Speech First lacked standing to sue, as the university’s team had no power to punish students, thereby minimizing the likelihood of self-censorship.


Violations Brought to Light

Credits: DepositPhotos

Speech First appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that Virginia Tech’s policy violated students’ First Amendment rights.


Disappointment Surfaces

Credit: Depositphotos

Despite the dismissal of the case, Speech First expressed disappointment but welcomed Virginia Tech’s decision to discontinue its bias response team. The organization reiterated its commitment to defending students’ free speech rights on campuses nationwide.


Commitment to Free Speech

Credit: DepositPhotos

In response, Virginia Tech emphasized its commitment to free speech and maintained that its policy complied with the First Amendment. The university assured the court that the policy would not be reinstated and highlighted its dedication to fostering open discourse and respecting students’ constitutional rights.


Broader Debate Continues

Credit: DepositPhotos

While the Supreme Court’s decision marks the end of this particular legal battle, the broader debate over free speech on college campuses continues, with implications for students’ rights and university policies nationwide.

Credit: DepositPhotos

Read More From The Stock Dork



Malik is a skilled writer with a passion for news and current events. With their keen eye for detail, they provide insightful perspectives on the latest happenings. Stay informed and engaged!