1. Home
  2. /
  3. Politics
  4. /
  5. Slideshow
  6. /
  7. Supreme Court To Review...

Supreme Court To Review Arbitration Status of Wonder Bread Truck Drivers

The Supreme Court will determine if Wonder Bread truck drivers are exempt from the Federal Arbitration Act as transportation workers.

This decision hinges on a specific provision of the act from 1925.

Arbitration Act Provisions

Credit: DepositPhotos

The Federal Arbitration Act exempts certain workers engaged in interstate commerce from mandatory arbitration.

Justices previously debated this exemption’s scope during oral arguments.

Historical Context

Credits: DepositPhotos

The court’s decision follows a 2022 ruling that recognized cargo loaders as exempt from arbitration.

The ruling emphasized the workers’ involvement in interstate commerce.

Preference for Arbitration

Credit: DepositPhotos

Companies favor arbitration for its efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

Critics, however, argue that courts offer more fairness to individuals.

Case Background

Credit: DepositPhotos

Neal Bissonnette and fellow truckers sued Flowers Foods, claiming misclassification as independent contractors.

They argue this status denied them rightful employee protections.

Misclassification Dispute

Credit: DepositPhotos

The drivers delivered bakery goods, asserting they performed roles similar to employees under strict company guidelines.

Flowers Foods, however, treated them as independent contractors.

Legal Challenges

Credit: DepositPhotos

In 2019, the drivers filed a lawsuit against Flowers Foods for misclassifying them and imposing illegal pay deductions.

Flowers attempted to move the case to arbitration based on the drivers’ contracts.

Court Decisions

Credit: DepositPhotos

A federal district court and the Second Circuit ruled against the drivers’ claim to be exempt from arbitration.

The courts’ decisions focused on the drivers’ classification and the nature of Flowers Foods’ business.

Split in Judicial Opinion

Credit: DepositPhotos

The Second Circuit found the drivers ineligible for the arbitration exemption, while the First Circuit ruled differently for another group of Flowers drivers.

This created a divide in court interpretations.

Oral Arguments Presented

Credit: DepositPhotos

The truckers’ attorney argued the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision supports their exemption from arbitration.

Flowers Foods’ interpretation of the exemption was challenged for being too narrow.

Flowers Foods’ Argument

Credit: DepositPhotos

Flowers Foods contended the drivers’ role did not fit the traditional definition of transportation workers exempt from arbitration.

The company’s lawyer argued the drivers’ primary role was selling, not transporting.

Supreme Court’s Concerns

Credits: DepositPhotos

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito expressed doubts about the rationale used by the Second Circuit.

They questioned the clarity and applicability of the court’s decision.

Anticipating the Ruling

Credit: DepositPhotos

The Supreme Court’s ruling is expected to clarify the arbitration exemption for transportation workers.

Its decision will have significant implications for workers and companies nationwide.

Read More From The Stock Dork

Credit: DepositPhotos